<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none;" alt="" src="https://ct.pinterest.com/v3/?event=init&tid=2613047792988&pd[em]=&noscript=1" /> Skip to Content

Fill Dirt vs Top Soil: What is the Difference

Sharing is caring!

Are you struggling to choose the right soil for your garden or just wondering about differences in ALL the soils? The success of your plants or whatever project you’re starting depends on it. 

One of the most common questions I see is specifically about the differences between fill dirt and top soil. I’ve used both over the years, and wish I’d had this information before I filled my first garden bed, so let’s explore the differences between topsoil and fill dirt to help you make an informed decision. 

By understanding the pros and cons of each type of soil and considering factors like budget and plant needs, you can make the best choice. So, let’s dig in and discover which option is best for you.

What is Topsoil?

Topsoil is exactly what it sounds like; the uppermost layer of soil, which typically consists of a mixture of organic material, minerals, and microorganisms. (All soil is alive, after all!) 

It’s used a lot in potting soil mixes, garden soil, and general soil applications. Understanding the composition and characteristics of this top layer of soil is essential in determining whether it is the right choice for your garden. Let’s explore the pros and cons of using topsoil to help you make an informed decision for your gardening needs.

Pros and Cons of Topsoil

Topsoil offers several advantages for gardeners. Here are some of the common pros for using topsoil:

  • It is rich in nutrients that help plants thrive, promoting healthy plant growth and vibrant blooms, so it’s a feasible option for vegetable gardens and flower beds. 
  • Easy to buy in bulk by the cubic yard
  • Many uses including lawn care applications and help for starting new grass.

Topsoil is also typically easier to work with than other types of soil, making it ideal for planting and landscaping projects. However, there are some drawbacks to consider when using topsoil. 

  • Topsoil can be more expensive than fill dirt, especially if you are purchasing a large quantity. 
  • The quality of topsoil can vary widely depending on where it is sourced, so it’s important to research and choose a reputable supplier. 

Despite these potential drawbacks, topsoil can be a valuable addition to your garden for its nutrient-rich properties and ease of use.

Fill dirt, on the other hand, is a different type of soil that serves distinct purposes in gardening and landscaping projects. I actually use topsoil in my DIY Potting Soil Recipe which can be used for container, raised beds, and more, so check it out if you’d like to save money on potting soil!

What Is Fill Dirt?

Fill dirt is often used to fill in holes or level out low spots, making it an essential component in construction sites and gardening projects. Unlike topsoil, this type of dirt does not contain as many nutrients and organic matter, which can make it less ideal for planting directly into. 

In fact, you can usually see the difference in fill dirt and top soil. Most fill dirt I have used has a gray color and lacks moisture.

However, fill dirt is an affordable option for filling in large areas or creating a stable foundation for different landscape projects. You may even be able to find free fill dirt. Let’s explore the pros and cons of using fill dirt in your garden or landscaping project.

Pros and Cons of Fill Dirt

So what are the benefits of fill dirt? And when would it be the right product to choose?

  • Cost effective
  • Many uses for different landscaping projects
  • Easy to come by

While fill dirt may be a cost-effective solution for filling in holes or creating a stable foundation for outdoor projects, there are some drawbacks to consider. 

  • Fill dirt lacks the nutrients and organic matter found in topsoil, making it less suitable for directly planting into. This means that additional soil amendments or fertilizers may be needed to support plant growth when using fill dirt. 
  • Fill dirt can be more compacted and may have a different texture than topsoil, which could cause water drainage problems and aeration issues in the garden. 

Despite these limitations, fill dirt can still be a useful resource for certain gardening and landscaping projects where nutrient-rich topsoil is not necessary. So it is important to weigh the pros and cons of fill dirt before deciding whether to use it in your garden or landscaping project. 

I personally used fill dirt in my first raised bed, since I didn’t know the differences. It was conveniently brought it by truck to fill on-site, which was super helpful, but it took years of amending to get the soil alive and vibrant. 

Factors to Consider When Choosing Soil for Your Garden

Factors to consider when choosing soil for your garden include the specific needs of your plants, the intended use of the soil, and the long-term goals for your garden’s health and vitality. Before making a decision between topsoil and fill dirt, think about the types of plants you will be growing and their requirements for nutrients, drainage, and aeration. 

If you’ve already used fill dirt or a lower quality top soil in your garden, and it’s struggling, be sure to check out my full article on How to Improve your Garden Soil. This is helpful info for all soil types and gives you common options to assess your soil and also improve it using different materials. 

Ultimately, whether you choose topsoil or fill dirt for your garden, the key is to prioritize soil quality to ensure the health of your plants and the overall well-being of your soil. By comparing the pros and cons of each option and considering factors like budget and plant needs, you can make an informed decision. Remember, healthy soil equals healthy plants. 

So, take the time to choose wisely and watch your garden thrive. As the saying goes, “To plant a garden is to believe in tomorrow.”

Ksenia

Thursday 6th of June 2024

I came here after trying to figure out what earth to buy in the store. Thanks for this clear explanation!

Courtney

Thursday 6th of June 2024

You're welcome!